HREFLANG for multiple country/language combinations
-
We have a site setup with English, German, French, Spanish and Italian. We offer these languages for every European country (over 30). Thus, there are 150 + different URL combinations, as we use the /country/language/ subdirectory path.
Should I list out every combination in hreflang?Or should I simply choose the most applicable combinations (/de/de and fr/fr, etc.)? If we go the latter path, should I block google bot from crawling the atypical combinations?
Best,
Sam
-
Hi Sam,
Apologies for the slow response. Your question slipped through the net.
This is an interesting case!
In an ideal world, you'd specify the relationship between all of those pages, in each direction. That's 150+ tags per page, though, which is going to cause some headaches. Even if you shift the tagging to an XML sitemap, that's a _lot _of weight and processing.
Anecdotally, I know that hreflang tagging starts to break at those kinds of scales (even more so on large sites, at that kind of scale, when the resultant XML sitemaps can reach the size of many gigabytes, or when Google is crawling faster than it's processing the hreflang directives), and so tagging everything isn't going to be a viable approach.
I'd suggest picking out and implementing hreflang for _only _the primary combinations*, as you suggest, and reducing the site-wide mapping to the primary variant in each case.
- You might consider that there may be cases where the valuable/primary combinations aren't just the /xx/xx/ or _/yy/yy/ _versions and that there might be some examples of varying country/language combinations which are worth including.
For the atypical variants, I think that you have a few options:
-
Use meta robots (or x-robots) tags to set noindex attributes. This will keep them out of the index, but doesn't guarantee that you're effectively managing/consolidating value across near duplicates - you may be quietly harming performance without realising it, as those pages represent points of crawl and value wastage/leakage.
-
Use robots.txt to prevent Google from accessing the atypical variants. That won't necessarily stop them from showing up in search results, though, and isn't without problems - you risk you creating crawl dead-ends, writing off the value of any inbound links to those pages, and other issues.
-
You use canonical URLs on all of the atypical variations, referencing the nearest primary version, to attempt to consolidate value/relevance etc. However, that risks the wrong language/content showing up in the wrong country, as you're explicitly _un_optimising the location component.
I think that #1 is the best approach, as per your thinking. That removes the requirement to do anything clever or manipulative with hreflang tagging, and fits neatly with the idea that the atypical combinations aren't useful/valuable enough to warrant their own identities - Google should be smart enough to fall back to the nearest 'generic' equivalent.
I'd also take care to set up your Google Search Console country targeting for each country-level folder, to reduce the risk of people ending up in the wrong sections.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Embedded site on directory from other country
Dear all, With Google search console I found my site embedded on some directories from other countries, with 1000 links to my site. E.g.: http://www.lmn24.com/it/go-scoopy-2714.html My question is: should I remove my embedded site on this directories? should I remove my embedded site if these directories have good DA (domain authority)?
Algorithm Updates | | Tormar0 -
Pages fluctuating +/- 70 positions in Google SERPs?
I've got some pages that appear somewhere around #25 in Google. Every now and then, it just goes away from the top 100 results for a few days (even up to a week) and then it comes back. I've got other pages that rank around #8 which falls down to about #75 for a while and then it comes back. But while a page may be gone from the top 100 results in the US, it still ranks at about the same place everywhere else in the world (+/- 10 positions). I've seen this happen in the past but never it happened so often. What gives?!?
Algorithm Updates | | sbrault740 -
Any Google Panda/Penguin, etc updates late October 2012?
Not sure why my website traffic is dropping down late Oct 12. It showed a boost with the last Panda update in early Oct. Anyone know of a current update?
Algorithm Updates | | ChrisTS0 -
Google Multiple Results
With Google's penchant for listing at times many results - one on top of the other - from the same domain, is it now advisable to not worry about having multiple pages in the same site targeting the same or very similar keywords? Is this (keyword/page internal competition) one less thing that I have to worry about or worry about less or what? Thanks! Best... Jane
Algorithm Updates | | 945010 -
Is it ok to repeat part of a meta-description across multiple pages?
For example, what if I was to conclude each meta-description tag with the line... "Free shipping for orders over $90." The rest of the meta-description tag on every page is unique, but the last sentence would be the same or at least similar. Thoughts?
Algorithm Updates | | B-man0 -
Gifts.com - Multiple domain pages in SERPs
One of our big natural search competitors for gift keywords is Gifts.com. We are competing for many keywords like "teen gifts", "gifts for him", "gifts for her". For many of these, the Google SERP has multiple Gifts.com pages on the first page. I have never seen more than one of our pages (uncommongoods.com) on a SERP page. Any clue how/why Gifts.com has multiple pages in search results ? Thanks!
Algorithm Updates | | znotes0 -
Rankings changing based on location within a country... normal?
I recently had a satellite office across the country come to me and say that they couldn't find us on Google, based on a number of keywords they were searching on. I thought that isn't right... I know we rank for those terms. So, I did a search here, and there we were for those very terms, and ranking quite nicely. Sooo, what's going on there? I know there are variations from Google.com to Google.ca in terms of ranking. But within Google.ca I've not seen this before. Can anyone shed some light on that?
Algorithm Updates | | atcosl0 -
Was I Kicked Off Google Page One by Panda/Farmer?
Took over this site in March. Got a Panicked call from client Mid-March that all of a sudden keywords that put the site on Page One weren't working. There are still 9 that work, but apparently there were more. A large percentage of the backlinks are from Article Directories and Link Farms. Is this my problem? Also, a large percentage of the 149 pages suffer from keyword stuffing and were obviously written for Search Engines and not people. How much of a difference does that make?
Algorithm Updates | | reeljerc0