Hide messenger for crawlers
-
At Magnet.me we are using Intercom to communicate with our users. This means that we are actively adding javascript code which will load the Intercom javascript on each page, and render the button afterwards.
However, this button has no value for crawlers, and slows the page down as the javascript is big and fairly slow. Therefore I considered to ship some code which disables this button, such that performance would improve. To give a ball pack estimate, the buttons javascript is around 3x bigger than the actual entire react application...
Unfortunately this would result in giving users and crawlers slightly different content on the page. I'm unsure about the possible SEO impact:
- Would Google mark the page as faster due to less resources to load?
- Or would it penalize the page for showing slightly different content to users and search engines?
-
In general, I don't think that this is a great idea. Although Google does meter out crawl-allowance, Google also wants a realistic view of the pages which it is crawling. Your attempt at easing the burden of Google's crawl-bots may be seen as an attempt to 'fake' good page-speed metrics, for example (by letting Google load the web-page much faster than end users). This could cause some issues with your rankings if uncovered by a 'dumb' algorithm (which won't factor in your good intentions)
Your efforts may also be unrequired. Although Google 'can' fire and crawl JavaScript generated elements, it doesn't always do so and it doesn't do that for everyone. If you read my (main) response to this question, you'll get a much better idea of what I'm talking about here. As such, the majority of the time - you may be taking on 'potential' risk for no reward
Would it be possible to code things slightly differently? Currently you state that this is your approach:
"This means that we are actively adding javascript code which will load the Intercom javascript on each page, and render the button afterwards"
Could you not add the button through HTML / CSS, and bind a smaller script to the button which then loads the "Intercom javascript"? I am assuming here that the "Intercom javascript" is the large script which is slowing the page(s) down. Why not load that script, only on request (seems logical, but also admit I am no dev - sorry)? It just seems as though more things are being initiated and loaded up-front than are really required
Google want to know which technologies are deployed on your page if they choose to look, they also don't want people going around faking higher page-speed loading scores
If you really want to stop Google wasting time on that script, your basic options would be:
- Code the site to refuse to serve the script to the "googlebot" user agent
- Block the script in robots.txt so that it is never crawled (directive only)
The first option is a little thermonuclear and may mean you get accused of cloaking (unlikely), or at the least 'faking' higher page-speed scores (more likely). The second option is only a directive which Google can disregard, so the risks are lower. The down-side is that Google will pick up on the blocked resource, and may not elevate your page-loading speed. Even if they do, they may say "since we can't view this script or know what it does, we don't know what the implication for end-users is so we'll dampen the rankings a little as a risk assessment factor"
Myself, I would look for an implementation that doesn't slow the site down so much (for users or search-bots). I get that it may be tricky, obviously re-coding the JS from Intercom would probably break the chat entirely. Maybe though, you could think about when that script has to be loaded. Is it really needed, on page-load, all the time for everyone? Or do people only need that functionality, when they choose to interact? How can you slot the loading of the code into that narrow trench, and get the best of both worlds?
Sorry it's not a super simple answer, hope it helps
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Is there an easy way to hide one of your URL's on google search?, rather than redirecting?
We don't want to redirect to a different page, as some people still use it, we just don't want it to appear in search
Technical SEO | | TheIDCo0 -
Hide mobile content element
Hello, We are optimizing our mobile (responsive) website at this moment and we want to change some elements on the productpage of our webshop in order of rank. This is the outcome of a data analysis which proves a change in rank of order will result in a higher conversion rate. No doubt. By technical limitations there is no other option but duplicating the element 'product description' in the source of the page to be able to show in on the spot on the product page we like to. Because our webshop is responsive we can not just move the element to the right spot for mobile because the tablet and desktop version then will change as well. My question is: will it be a problem for Google if we hide the original element of the product description on mobile pages by using the bootstrap class "hidden-xs" and duplicate it on another spot in the page to show it with the "visible-xs" class? My concern is that this will create duplicate content and hiding content for Google is not particularly good. On the other hand, I think Google is smart enough to understand that this is not to manipulate visitors or rankings, but this is only for a different look of the mobile website. I hope you guys can give me some good advice.
Technical SEO | | MarcelMoz
Thanks in advance.
Marcel0 -
Block bad crawlers
Hi! how are you? I've been working on some of my sites, and noticed that i'm getting lots of crawls by search engines that i'm not intereted in ranking well. My question is the following: do you have a list of 'bad behaved' search engines that take lots of bandwidth and don´t send much/good traffic? If so, do you know how to block them using robots.txt? Thanks for the help! Best wishes, Ariel
Technical SEO | | arielbortz0 -
Will a google map loaded "on scroll" be ignored by the crawler?
One of my pages has two Google maps on it. This leads to a fairly high keyword density for words like "data", "map data" etc. Since one of the maps is basically at the bottom of the page I thought of loading it "on scroll" as soon as its container becomes visible (before loading the map div should be empty). Will the map then still be craweld by google (can they execute the JS in a way that the map is loaded anyways?) or would this help to reduce the keywords introduced by the maps?
Technical SEO | | ddspg0 -
How many times robots.txt gets visited by crawlers, especially Google?
Hi, Do you know if there's any way to track how often robots.txt file has been crawled? I know we can check when is the latest downloaded from webmaster tool, but I actually want to know if they download every time crawlers visit any page on the site (e.g. hundreds of thousands of times every day), or less. thanks...
Technical SEO | | linklater0 -
Will Google hit me because I hide my H1 tag?
I read an article this morning regarding keywords on a web page. In the article it said that Google would hit anyone putting keywords on a web page but then hiding them from anyone visiting the website. This makes sense. What it did make me think about though is the technique I use when building a website. If, for example, I'm building a website for "Acme Cheap Products". In the header of the page, I will have a H1 tag as well as an image tag for the company's logo. As the logo has the company name on it, I would usually put the company name in a H1 tag as well, and then hide the H1 tag, so I wouldn't have a logo and then a title next to it saying the same thing as the logo. The question is though, would this sort of technique trigger Google in to hitting my site?
Technical SEO | | -Al-0 -
Duplicate Content Issue: Google/Moz Crawler recognize Chinese?
Hi! I am using Wordpress multisite and my Chinese version of the website is in www.mysite.com/cn Problem: I keep getting duplicate content errors within www.mysite.com/cn (NOT between www.mysite.com and www.mysite.com/cn) I have downloaded and checked the SEOmoz report and duplicate_page_content list in CSV file. I have no idea why it says they have the same content., they have nothing in common in content . www.mysite.com is the English version of the website,and the structure is the same for www.mysite.com/cn *I don't have any duplicate content issues within www.mysite.com Question: Does google Crawler properly recognizes chinese content??
Technical SEO | | joony20080 -
Mobile SEO or Block Crawlers?
We're in the process of launching mobile versions of many of our brand sites and our ecommerce site and one of our partners suggested that we should block crawlers on the mobile view so it doesn't compete for the same keywords as the standard site (We will be automatically redirecting mobile handsets to the mobile site). Does this advice make sense? It seems counterintuitive to me.
Technical SEO | | BruceMillard0