Panda recovery. Is it possible ?
-
Dear all,
To begin, english is not my native language, so I'm very sorry if I make some mistake.
On the 23th march 2012, Panda penalized my website (a coupon website) Avec-Reduction (dot com for the url). At this date, I have lost more than 70% of my traffic.
The structure of the website was like an e-commerce website. Categories -> merchant page -> coupon page. The content was to thin for Google, I'm agree wit that.
So, in may, I have made a new version. Here you can see the most important modifications :
- A smallest header (-100px height).
- 2 columns website (the oldest website had 3 columns)
- I have deleted the category menu with the list of all categories and the alphabetical menu.
- less ads on the website (since few days I have also deleted the 2 adense blocks)
- The coupons was promoted with the thumbs of the merchant on the home listing. Now I have few top lists in text only.
- I have deleted all the categories pages (one page by category of merchant, with the listing of all the merchants of the category). Now I have only one page for this. Same thing with the alphabetical pages. All these deleted pages have a 301 redirect. The 2 new pages (categorie page and alphabetical page) are on noindex.
- I have deleted all the promo codes pages, all the coupons are now on the merchant page (301 redirect used).
- I have create an anti-spam system for the review codes (I have a lot of spam on these forms, even if I cleaned every day/2days). Now, I have no spam.
- Visitors have now the possibility to put a note and a review for each merchant. This fonctionality is new, so not a lot of reviews for the moment.
- All the merchants pages without promo codes have a noindex on the robot tag.
- Since july, I have the possibility to use the "title" of each promo code. I can personnalised the promo code. On the same time, to have more content, I have the possibility to add sales or great promos for each merchants, not only promo codes.
- Affiliate links are created on JS which open a new window (a redirect page with noindex).
That's the end of the most important changes on my website. I have a better speed page (/2 since july) because I have optimized my images, CSS, JS...
At the end of july, I had health problem and the website has no update until the first days of october. Now, the website is updated every day, but between july and october I have no panda recovery.
I have no duplicate content, I try to add the most content I can. So I don't understand why Google Panda penalized me again and again. Some of my competitors have a lot of keyword stuffing (4, 5, 6, ... 10 lines of KS on each merchant pages). Some of them have only affiliate merchants, automatic script to put coupons on websites), few "same" websites...
I have less than 30% of affiliated merchant, I validate all the coupons or promo manually, I personalized all my coupons... So I don't understand what to do.
I will appreciate all help. If you see problems on my wesite or if you know tips to have a panda recovery, I will be very happy to have informations.
Many thanks for all.
Sincerely,
Florent
-
Dear Edward,
You are right. I have seen some US/UK coupons websites with informations about the company or the website (payment methods, shipping methods...). I think it's a good idea to have better content. On France, there are not a lot of coupons websites with these types of informations. The market on our country is important but less thant country like USA. So, a lot of websites are made automaticly, in few days some webmasters have few coupons website and they win money because they have a network with power.
I think I will use this option on the near future. 2600 merchants, it will be long to add these informations but if it's possible to have a Panda Recovery, I think it's not a hard work, just necessary.
Thx for your help.
Sincerely,
F.
-
I've worked with a few Coupon/Promo Codes sites since the launch of Penguin with some success and some failure. The biggest issues I've found between coupon sites is a lack of truly original content and very thin content, with pages frequently saying the same thing as other pages but slightly re-worded. Duplicate content issues are usually common as well.
Ex: "Check out our coupon codes for [company/website]...[more filler text here]."
One strategy that seems to be fairly effective (and logical) for such sites is filling the retailer coupon pages with information relevant to the coupons (which obviously vary) as well as the company. Ex: company history, background, etc. -- content that's truly unique from page to page.
-
Dear eyepaq,
Many thanks for your reply, that's great.
Like you say, I'm sure that my change are good for the future so when the panda filter (sorry for having used the word penality, in France we used the word "filtre", it's difficult to speak in other language :p).
you don't have to be good to stay safe or recover from panda, you need to be better then the rest of the sites that are covering the same niche.
I'm ok with that, that's the only point on which I have no idea to be better. I have see all the most important US coupons websites to help me but they are to big for me. Technically they are better, better design and I think they have a lot of persons which work every day for the website. In France, there are less competitors, 5 biggest and all the other are very simple website like mine.
+ panda it's only about the content (site speed, affiliate format, links etc are not taking into account - for those you have other filters and penalties)
I know, but havind a better speed is good for visitor. I think it's good for Google to show that speed page is important for the website.
Spot the ones that are still up and try to improve the content in order to be better then those are have a different approach for the same niche / area in order to get a spot for the diverse spots. In this way you will get back.
I will work on this :).
First assess the situation and see if you can be better - in terms of content - then those that are still on top in visibility that are targeting more or less the same content as you do. If you can beat them - change your content strategy and approach the same content in a different format and flow in order to make it on the top results as one of the sites that are part of the diversity results.
Ok but it's very difficult. I use 2 websites on my niche that have better traffic than. Why these 2 websites ? Only because they have a simple design and not a lot of options on the merchant pages. These 2 websites have problems which I haven't got but no pand filter and better traffic. The reason ? They are oldest than me and they have a lot of links (one have more 1 million link). So it's not very clean but they rank well.
Just a last question. Do you think it's better for me to "crypt" the coupon code (on the html code) ? Why ? Just because Google can see that we have all the same code. If I use a crypt code, perhaps it will be better to say "I have unique content" ? Do you think that it'a a good idea ?
Once again many thanks for your post. You are very clear for me and you give me another vision to solve my problem :).
Sincerely,
Florent
-
Hi Florent,
All the changes that you did are very good and for sure it will help your site - but not necessarily on the Panda issue.
When talking about panda you need to consider a few things:
-
panda is not a penalty - it's a filter (very important difference)
-
you don't have to be good to stay safe or recover from panda, you need to be better then the rest of the sites that are covering the same niche.
-
panda it's only about the content (site speed, affiliate format, links etc are not taking into account - for those you have other filters and penalties)
So, fi you are 100% that Panda is to blame for your drop in rankings you need to compare your self with the competition first and see how can you be better then them.
Just put your self in Google shoes - if you have 10 sites on the same niche with more or less the same content you want to keep 1 or 2, populate the rest of the results with diverse results and move the rest -50 or whatever.
If you are not the one on the 1 or 2 set then you are one of the one that just got moved back - way back (down).
Spot the ones that are still up and try to improve the content in order to be better then those are have a different approach for the same niche / area in order to get a spot for the diverse spots. In this way you will get back.
First assess the situation and see if you can be better - in terms of content - then those that are still on top in visibility that are targeting more or less the same content as you do. If you can beat them - change your content strategy and approach the same content in a different format and flow in order to make it on the top results as one of the sites that are part of the diversity results.
Hope it helps. Is it clear or I am beating around the bush ?
Cheers !
-
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Shall I hide short product review texts from customers (to avoid google panda/quality issues)?
About 30% of product reviews that the clients of our ecommerce store submitted in the last 10 years are 3 words or less (we did not require any minimum length). Would you recommend to hide those very short review texts? Where to draw the limit?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | lcourse
Numeric star rating would still go into our accumulated product rating. My only concern here is what impact it may have on google ranking.
To give some context, the site has for a long time some panda/phantom related issues where there are no obvious reasons that we could point to.0 -
My client wants to apply schematic markup to their iframe youtube video. Is this possible?
I have a client that wants to apply video object schema to their iframe youtube video. Here is the source code: <iframe src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/clientvideo" width="272" height="202" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen=""></iframe> Is it possible to apply schema markup to this kind of iframe source code? Our development team was having a hard time with it. Thanks!
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | RosemaryB0 -
Has My Site Been Hit by Panda 4.0?
I operate a New York City commercial real estate web site (www.nyc-officespace-leader.com). Ranking and traffic have dropped steeply since early June. Around May 20th a new Panda update was launched by Google and I wonder if that could partially explain the drop. My site contains the following: -300 listing pages. These are product pages and often contain less than 100 words. Many have not been changed in two years. -150 Building pages. These contain less than 220 words. Many have not been changed in two years. -40 blog pages. We have been adding 1 or 2 per month. -50 or 60 neighborhood and type of space pages. These contain 200-600 words. Could our drop in traffic be due to Panda? I might add that an upgraded version of the site with new forms, a modified right rail an header was launched on June 6th. Also, we submitted a disavow file with Google on April 20th for about 100 toxic domains, one third of the 300 domains that link to us. In order to take remedial action we need to understand what has happened. Any ideas??? Thanks, Alan
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Kingalan10 -
Penguin Recovery Possible Solution (when all fails...)?
Hi, INTRO We were hit pretty bad - first with unnatural links warning and then (we assume) by penguin. We removed a lot of links and disavowed the removed along with all others we couldn't.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | BeytzNet
The manual penalization was revoked but the site is still down. I understand that Penguin and Unnatural links are not the same.
I assume that while our removal and fixes were enough for the manual penalty to be removed the penguin algorithm still disapproves us. Also, I am not expecting to be where we were but we know our current locations don't make sense (several pages seem to be de-indexed). AND THE QUESTION... SINCE ALL HAS FAILED, we consider removing the main landing pages (which were the target for link-building) and build new ones with new URLs. In the old ones placing 404 and not 301. This means that all the spammy links that were built will point to non-existing pages (404)
(besides for those that point to the homepage...) Do you think it will resolve the problem? Or since the spammy links still point to our domain we are still in a problem? (even if to 404 pages). The way we see it, it is the last resort prior to dropping the domain! Thanks0 -
WMT Index Status - Possible Duplicate Content
Hi everyone. A little background: I have a website that is 3 years old. For a period of 8 months I was in the top 5 for my main targeted keyword. I seemed to have survived the man eating panda but not so sure about the blood thirsty penguin. Anyway; my homepage, along with other important pages, have been wiped of the face of Google's planet. First I got rid of some links that may not have been helping and disavowed them. When this didn't work I decided to do a complete redesign of my site with better content, cleaner design, removed ads (only had 1) and incorporated social integration. This has had no effect at all. I filed a reconsideration request and was told that I have NOT had any manual spam penalties made against me, by the way I never received any warning messages in WMT. SO, what could be the problem? Maybe it's duplicate content? In WMT the Index Status indicates that there are 260 pages indexed. However; I have only 47 pages in my sitemap and when I do a site: search on Google it only retrieves 44 pages. So what are all these other pages? Before I uploaded the redesign I removed all the current pages from the index and cache using the remove URL tool in WMT. I should mention that I have a blog on Blogger that is linked to a subdomain on my hosting account i.e. http://blog.mydomain.co.uk. Are the blog posts counted as pages on my site or on Blogger's servers? Ahhhh this is too complicated lol Any help will be much appreciated! Many thanks, Mark.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Nortski0 -
Website Survived Last Year Penguin & Panda Updates but dropped Jan 2013?
Hi, I have a website which was gaining good rankings through 2012 and even looked in pretty good shape after all of the Penguin and Panda updates in 2012 but in Jan 2013 the sites rankings have been very poor as it dropped for all terms. It is still in the index and webmaster tools shows the sites keywords but is showing places of 100 or so rather than 10 - 16 in the seeps. The website is www.mywebsitehosting.org Any ideas why this has dropped in January and what can I do to fix it? Thanks. P.s I have made a change to the homepage content but inner pages for the website also dropped to which have the same content as they did a few months ago.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | firebubble0 -
Examples of sites other than Hubpages that have used subdomains to recover from Panda?
Everyone knows subdomains worked for Hubpages to recover from Panda. Does anyone know of other examples of sites that have recovered from Panda using subdomains?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | nicole.healthline0 -
Has Panda 2.5 Hit?
I'm sure a few people have been asking this direct question throughout the forums but most of them are masked by indirect questions like "my traffic has dipped" and the like. Does anyone have a firm confirmation that Panda has hit? My indication that it has hit is that I'm experiencing a ~%30 increase in traffic to my e-commerce client from organic searches after this past weekend. We haven't made any significant changes to content besides daily postings, but even that doesn't account for a %30 spike that has maintained for 3 days straight. So again, what have you guys experienced? Anything to support this?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | linztm0