Have I broken the rules?
-
I am not an SEO by any means and would appreciate any advice I can get as I try to understand this field just a tiny bit better. I own an Etsy shop and have a blog that promotes my products (party supplies) and feature birthday parties that have been thrown by moms/party planner, etc. I've been fortunate to meet a group of great blogging friends in my niche along the way. Every Friday, we have been sharing one post from each other's blog in a round up post to try and drive a bit of traffic to each other. Is this something that would be penalized by Google?
Thanks so much for your time.
-
Probably no better proof we are kid's party bloggers trying to pick up a bit of knowledge and not SEOs Ha! Thanks for pointing that out - and so generously giving of your time.
-
Also the link to spaceships and laser beams from this page is mis-formed http://www.thislittlemama.com/2013/03/21/stephanie-keeping/
-
Rounds up posts are just fine. The problem is if they are is a close group of people who just recommend each other, it looks un-natural. E.g. these are fine:
http://www.threethriftyguys.com/2013/05/friday-finds-510/
http://coolmaterial.com/roundup/friday-link-roundup-123/
Its find to recommend your friends, but not all the time. Also once you have a few links from a site additional links from the site site become less valuable so you want to have a bigger a bigger pool of sites that link to you.
-
I have been thinking more about this and I have a follow up question - if it's not too much of an overstep. These weekly round up posts I do are actually quite popular, they get shared socially, I get blog comments, etc. Everyone writes their own post that fits with their particular blog. Is there any way where these weekly group roundups work? It seems a shame to stop it. I just want to make sure we're doing more good than harm.
-
Thanks so much. Very helpful.
No, there's no drop in ranking, I'm just learning more about SEO and realized what we believe is community building (we're all in the same niche) might be frowned upon.
-
Hi Stephanie,
Firstly, google doesn't really have "rules", instead they publish "webmaster guidelines", you should read and understand them, see here: http://support.google.com/webmasters/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=35769
In the purest sense yes you have broken this guideline:
"Avoid participating in link schemes"
Read here: http://support.google.com/webmasters/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=66356
I don't think you and your friends intended to "manipulate your site's ranking in Google", but that is how it looks to google, you intended to sent traffic to each other from your current readers.
Another problem is duplicate content, it sounds like your group is publishing the same content on each other's sites. This is not good, please stop and also consider going back and removing all duplicate content, just leave the original live.
I assume you are posting here because your traffic and rankings on google have dropped is that correct?
Finally, I think you need to keep your blogging friends but also to make some new ones. If there are 10 blogs in this group and you all interlink to each other and on a regular basis it isn't going to look good in google's eyes.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Dead/Broken links on old blogs
Hi We are currently trying to update our blog page on our website but quickly realized there are numerous dead or broken 404 links after clicking on anchor text from past blog posts. Our blog is set up in WordPress and we recently installed an SEO plug in with it. Some of these anchor texts don't actually need links and I want to unlink them, is there a simple way to do this on WordPress? Other anchor text I would like to "301 redirect" to another page. Can i do this on WordPress or is this something my SEO plugin should be able to fix? Answers are much appreciated! Thanks
Link Building | | SapphireCo0 -
Broken Backlinking
I'm curious for those who have used broken backlinking as a tactic for clients - what % of emails do you normally get results from. For example, if you email 100 webmasters, how many would actually replace the broken link with yours?
Link Building | | ImprezzioMarketing0 -
Broken Incoming Links from External Site - What to do?
Our Google Webmaster 'page not found' reports consistently show two Chinese websites that have approximately 50 broken links each to non-existent pages on our website. One site is a PR5, the other a PR1. Two of our Chinese employees have contacted the site owners (even talking with them over the phone) to discuss the errors, where the broken links live on their sites, and how to fix them. They have contacted the site owners three times in the past three months, but still the broken links have not be fixed. What do you recommend we do?
Link Building | | Prospector-Plastics0 -
Looking for Resources for Broken backlink Building With My Team
I've been doing some reading on broken backlink building but have not had much success with implementing a fine tuned process with my team. I've already read the moz post about broken backlink building. I've also used the www.<a>brokenlinkbuilding</a><a>.com</a> tool by citation labs but found it to be kind of clunky. Could have just been me though : ). Any helpful resources would be appreciated to automate the process better?
Link Building | | Keith-Eneix0 -
Where can I get a list of broken links to my client's website?
I have a client who owns a website that attracted a large number of links to internal pages of their sites. Without realising the value of those links, they removed every page of their website other than the home pages that now reads, "new website coming soon". How can I get a list of every website still linking to the (now broken) internal pages of their site?
Link Building | | richdan0 -
What value do external broken links give to a domain?
I ask, as I've just used opensite explorer to look at external links a competitor has, and I've found the high value ones at the top of the list go to a page that no longer exists on their site. Are these stiill of value in the SERP's, or have they messed up by not putting a 301 redirect on them?
Link Building | | xposurecreative0 -
About buy broken links...
I found some web adress that are not online anymore.. but when I open these adresses on open site explorer I can see links and page athority for these domains... PA 41 and DA 29 My question is... Can I buy these adress and using their page and rank juice to my website? Because they are avaliable... All these domains are from my country and LTD What can I do...? Thank you
Link Building | | lans27870 -
Broken back links
I have noticed that some of the back links built for us by our SEO agency we have no longer work. Is there is a common view on the percentage of back links generally do not work say after a year or so. If there is an acceptable number, want to give to my SEO agency as a KPI?
Link Building | | kesh-2833120