Why my WMT is showing more clicks than my Google Analytics Organic Search Traffic?
-
Hello Everybody,
Can somebody help me figure out this puzzle:
My WMT is showing 6000 clicks, while my Organic Traffic in Google Analytics is showing only 3500 daily ... how is that possible?
Best Regards
-
Hey William,
thats quite a beautiful educating response you have there:-)
helped me a lot in phrasing my problem better and doing a thorough better check.
still looking into the responses in the post you linked to here, and it is quite lots of options, lots of information but a very enlightening post !
Thanks for your referal to that post and will update you if one of the options in the comments there will turn to be explaining what we have.
Best Wishes
-
Hello Jane,
Thanks for your response. we did have other problems with the placing of the GA code in our general page code, but meanwhile its loaded right after the header with only some few Javascript directories in the header.
Added this to the development team requests in order to be sure. though I wonder if this is it.
Will update here if we fix this soon to be sure that firing the GA code first will solve such a problem.
We do deal with targeted audiences with slow internet thats for sure.
So thanks for highlighting this option!
Best Wishes
-
WMT and GA data rarely matches up perfectly, but William's point about the GA code not working for whatever reason is important.
My former agency wrote our own analytics code for one client site. It was a small piece of JavaScript. The client placed it below a very slow-loading piece of conversion rate optimisation JS that took a very long time to load. Most people coming to the website knew what they wanted from the home page quite quickly and we had about 50% of our SEO traffic clicking away from the home page before our code had loaded. As a result, a huge amount of our traffic was missing from our weekly reports: we could only report on those people who'd stayed on the home page for long enough to have our code load, or who had landed on other pages and taken longer to figure out what they wanted or who had come to the page they wanted immediately.
We had our code moved up in the page code. JavaScript processes commands as they appear in the code, so our code loaded "immediately" after it was placed high in the code, and the CRO code did its thing afterwards. Our traffic went back up (after we had been through hours of explaining that rankings and interest had not dropped, so it was absolutely a tracking problem and not a real traffic problem).
Not saying this is happening here, but take a look at the page load times, JS on the page and placement of the GA code, plus raw server logs if you have access to them, and see if there is possibly a tracking problem with GA.
-
Nice explanation William.
-
WMT measures clicks from Google. This data is gathered directly from Google's properties before the visitor sees your website. On the other hand, GA measures traffic based on a script on your website that has to fire and send data back to Google. If this script doesn't fire, no data goes to Google.
There are multiple reasons why this script may not fire, including mistakes during implementation, someone leaving the page before the script loads, browsers that don't load javascript, security programs that block the code from firing, and so on. All of those factors can attribute to variations in data.
I think it's good to use both sources. When you're in a data-driven industry, it's good to collect lots of it
Here is a post that goes a little deeper, the comments are especially intriguing: http://www.notprovided.eu/why-not-use-googles-wmt-data/
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Google Analytics direct traffic dropped by 50% after switching to https
Hi, everyone, have a little dilemma and was hoping to get some advice here. I recently installed a new SSL (3 months ago) to force our URL to start with https://. The site was earlier accessible through https:// and http:// prefix however now I have made it so that all urls are redirected to the correct https:// version. The problem is that direct traffic has dropped by more than 50% after implementing these changes and I can for the life of me figure out why. Why would the direct traffic drop all of sudden after making these changes? I am starting to suspect that the earlier data was inflated and that Google analytics was counting users coming from a http:// version of the URL to a https:// version of the URL was counted as direct traffic. Could that be it? Any other possible causes? Would really appreciate any guidance on this problem. Thanks
Reporting & Analytics | | nsereke0 -
Google Search Console - > Google Search Analytic gives figure for google organic or adwords or combine of both?
Hi All, In Google Search Console -> In Search Analytics. I can see Clicks, Impressions, CTR and Position. I want to know all these 4 - Clicks, Impressions, CTR and Position gives information related to google organic only? or combine or google organic and google adwords? Thanks!
Reporting & Analytics | | wright3350 -
How to Configure Custom Alerts for Real Time Traffic etc from Google Analytic API?
Hi All, I know how to set alert from google analytic but i want alerts for real time visitors so i think it is possible via Google Analytic API, so can anyone share with me the process or relevant blog post? Regards, Mit
Reporting & Analytics | | mit0 -
In Analytic Ipad Traffic Showing in Desktop, tablet and Mobile all 3 is it possible?
Hi, In Google Analytic when i see Mobile Overview in secondary dimension when i select Mobile device Model and when i search Ipad then i can see ipad in tablet, desktop and mobile why is it so? Ipad traffic and transaction should appear only on mobile whey it is showing on desktop and tablet? John..
Reporting & Analytics | | varo0 -
Can you arrange Google Analytics source/medium traffic by percentage change?
I'm doing a year to year traffic audit for a client. I would like to analyze Google Analytics source/medium traffic by percent change. Is there a way to do this? Do I have to create a custom variable? 9BH70RO
Reporting & Analytics | | VanguardCommunications0 -
Weird Google Analytics tracking question
I have a client that has a market place site, where people list goods and sell them, think something like Etsy. Instead of developing a system to show the users page views and things like that, does it sound reasonable to let them enter a Google Analytics property on the pages they list on, then let them monitor through GA? Does anyone see any fatal flaws in this thinking?
Reporting & Analytics | | LesleyPaone0 -
Google Analytics set up for non-canonicalized domains
Our client's website is non-canonicalized (www.example.com & example.com load the same thing). Google seems to have made a preference for the www, but canonicalizing to www breaks their Flash website. All we're really trying to do at this time is install Google Analytics for them. What's the smartest way to make sure that both www.example.com and example.com are treated exactly the same by Google Analytics? Google Developers: Domains & Directories states that by default visit data will be separately collected between the two domains, although I found no references to the common www/naked domain issue. In stackoverflow: Does google analytics combine naked domains with the www subdomain? Török Gábor says, "Yes, users will be tracked, but the same visitor coming from www.datalookups.com and datalookups.com will be counted as two different visitors." On the same page, Open SEO says, "This is completely false: www.domain.tld and domain.tld are treaded just the same, and get the same value for the HASH code (the number at the start of each __utm cookie). This an exception: every other subdomain.domain.tld will be handeld as a distinct web site". Can any Analytics experts help me sort this out? Thanks!
Reporting & Analytics | | GOODSIR0 -
Google and bing search filed commands
Dose someone have / know a full list / resource with commands for google and bing ? Including filters for those commands ? (site:domain.com -filter etc) (like: site:domain.com, link:domain.com etc) I use the basic ones b ut I know there are much more and that there are several filters that can be used with success to filter down results. Thanks.
Reporting & Analytics | | eyepaq1