How do I avoid this issue of duplicate content with Google?
-
I have an ecommerce website which sells a product that has many different variations based on a vehicle’s make, model, and year. Currently, we sell this product on one page “www.cargoliner.com/products.php?did=10001” and we show a modal to sort through each make, model, and year. This is important because based on the make, model, and year, we have different prices/configurations for each. For example, for the Jeep Wrangler and Jeep Cherokee, we might have different products:
Ultimate Pet Liner - Jeep Wrangler 2011-2013 - $350
Ultimate Pet Liner - Jeep Wrangler 2014 - 2015 - $350
Utlimate Pet Liner - Jeep Cherokee 2011-2015 - $400
Although the typical consumer might think we have 1 product (the Ultimate Pet Liner), we look at these as many different types of products, each with a different configuration and different variants.
We do NOT have unique content for each make, model, and year. We have the same content and images for each. When the customer selects their make, model, and year, we just search and replace the text to make it look like the make, model, and year. For example, when a custom selects 2015 Jeep Wrangler from the modal, we do a search and replace so the page will have the same url (www.cargoliner.com/products.php?did=10001) but the product title will say “2015 Jeep Wrangler”.
Here’s my problem:
We want all of these individual products to have their own unique urls (cargoliner.com/products/2015-jeep-wrangler) so we can reference them in emails to customers and ideally we start creating unique content for them. Our only problem is that there will be hundreds of them and they don’t have unique content other than us switching in the product title and change of variants. Also, we don’t want our url www.cargoliner.com/products.php?did=10001 to lose its link juice.
Here’s my question(s):
My assumption is that I should just keep my url: www.cargoliner.com/products.php?did=10001 and be able to sort through the products on that page. Then I should go ahead and make individual urls for each of these products (i.e. cargoliner.com/products/2015-jeep-wrangler) but just add a “nofollow noindex” to the page.
Is this what I should do?
How secure is a “no-follow noindex” on a webpage? Does Google still index?
Am I at risk for duplicate content penalties?
Thanks!
-
Hi Don,
Using these generic blocks for multiple products is an awesome idea, but don't you think it'll end up creating almost duplicate content section on all these product pages?
Does bots consider duplicate content across the page, or section wise?
-
The only thing I'd add to this is to that nofollow isn't secure enough. I would recommend blocking the individual product pages that you don't want search engines to find. Thanks Donford for the detailed response.
Craig
-
Thanks for your response Don. I have a followup question for you.
I did understand your your t-shirt example but I think it's even more refined in our case. Since there are so many different variants, we do have to count them as different products, and we would like to avoid creating custom content right away (there's just so much we would have to create). I'm still thinking our perfect solution would be custom links but with a canonical tag pointing back to "www.cargoliner.com/products.php?did=10001".
Here's my solution based on your advise:
I'm going to keep my main page where people can sort to find there make, model, and year (www.cargoliner.com/products.php?did=10001).
Then I plan to have specific product pages per make, model, and year which will have duplicate content except for the make, model, and year searched and replaced. ie Jeep Wrangler 2015-2016 will be "www.cargoliner/products/jeep-wrangler-2015-2016" and in that page I will have a canonical tag point back to "www.cargoliner.com/products.php?did=10001" so I don't get hit with duplicate content.
After this and over the next 6-9 months, I plan to fill in all of the custom content for each product. Then I plan to remove the canonical tag once I have custom content on that page.
Does this sound like the correct approach?
-
Hi Kirby,
What you have here is a common hurdle to many online businesses. Just like a company selling T-shirts, they may have a smiley face t-shirt in s, m, l, xl, xxl and in 5 different colors. So how does one optimize their content to be found when somebody searches for XL red smiley face t-shirt?
You can take one of two approaches.
Option 1: You can optimize a page for the "main item" in my example it would be "smiley face t-shirt". Then try to get the long tailed keywords on the page by listing colors, sizes, on the page a couple times. The goal of this page would be to rank #1 for the broad keyword Smiley Face T-Shirt, and high on longer keywords like XL Smiley Face T-Shirts, and Red Smiley Face T-shirt. With this approach you would use parameters for items, so you could generate a unique url, but you would canonical it back to the main page.
So the main page would look like this:
url: thetshirtShop.us/mens-tees/smilely-face-tshirt
Title: Smiley Face T-Shirt, Men's Small Through XL
H1: Men's Smiley Face T-Shirt, S,M,L,XL, 2XL, Select A Color & SizeThen for each option you would have your parameters (example red, XL)
url: thetshirtShop.us/mens-tees/smilely-face-tshirt?size=XL&color=red
Canonical: thetshirtShop.us/mens-tees/smiely-face-tshirtThat is the basic structure, but be sure in your content you include the color's and sizes at least twice so when the page is crawled the crawlers see the sizes and colors.
Option 2: which in my opinion is the better of the two would be to create unique content for each item. I know this may seem like it would be difficult or time consuming, and to a degree it is. Again how much different is a red t-shirt from a green one? Aside from the color not much, but there is opportunity here.
Example option 2 color red / xl
url: thetshirtShop.us/mens-tees/smilely-face-tshirt?size=XL&color=red
Title: Red Smiley Face T-Shirt Men's Size XL
H1: Men's Red Smilely Face T-Shirt Size XLContent Block (Smiley Face T)
By artist Harvest Ross Ball the smiley face t-shirt puts a smile on your chest and a positive attitude by on-lookers. Staying true to the original creator the smiley face tee has been digital optimized and transferred to the tee using our proprietary screen process that insures the image will last. This is one of best selling iconic tees and available in colors, yellow, red, black, white and green. Men's U.S standard sizes, small, medium, large, extra large, and extra extra large.Content Block (Color-Red):
The T-Shirt Shop using the finest natural dyes in creating our vibrant red color for {Smiley Face T-Shirt}. Using red hibiscus, sumac berries and beets. Our red color is formulated to last for thousands of washes with no fading or wash bleeding. The end result we get true red {Smiley Face T-Shirt} which is quality tested to be HEX #FF0000 RGB 255,0,0 +- within 2 shades.Content Block (Size XL):
Our Men's Size XL for our {Red} {Smiley Face T-Shirt} follows U.S sizing standards; width 24" (61 cm), length 31.25" (80cm). Sleeve length for the {Red} {Smiley Face T-Shirt} is 9" (22cm), and can accommodate up to a 16" (40cm) bicep comfortably. All our T's are pre-washed and pre-shrunk to ensure our high sizing standards are meet.Okay, so let me break down what I did here. I created 2 different "specific" code blocks with dynamic elements inside them noted by the { } brackets. Along with the original description block. You can reuse these blocks for other t-shirts, and still achieve a unique page. For example:
Smiley Face T (red/xl) Content Blocks = Smiley Face T, Red, XL
Smiley Face T (green/large) Content Blocks = Smiley Face T, Green, LargeUsing these code blocks with dynamic insertion of product details you can achieve a unique page. However you need to get creative in writing these blocks, and do some back end coding or extra work in getting them uploaded to the thousands of different products properly. Just to note I have no knowledge of t-shirts or how best to market them, I just used this for an example to help you identify possible areas of creativity in your product.
In summary I have laid out 2 options for this problem. You can use parameters with canonical and a single page, or get creative and make some unique content pages. Each option will achieve unique urls for your email campaign, and follow SEO best practices.
Hope this helps,
Don
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Google serp pagination issue
We are a local real estate company and have landing pages for different communities and cities around our area that display the most recent listings. For example: www.mysite.com/wa/tumwater is our landing page for the city of Tumwater homes for sale. Google has indexed most of our landing pages, but for whatever reason they are displaying either page 2, 3, 4 etc... instead of page 1. Our Roy, WA landing page is another example. www.mysite.com/wa/roy has recently been showing up on page 1 of Google for "Roy WA homes for sale", but now we are much further down and www.mysite.com/wa/roy?start=80 (page 5) is the only page in the serps. (coincidentally we no longer have 5 pages worth of listings for this city, so this link now redirects to www.mysite.com/wa/roy.) We haven't made any major recent changes to the site. Any help would be much appreciated! *You can see what my site is in the attached image... I just don't want this post to show up when someone google's the actual name of the business 🙂 nTTrSMx.jpg C4mhfgh.jpg
Technical SEO | | summithomes0 -
Is this going to be seen by google as duplicate content
Hi All, Thanks in advance for any help that you can offer in regards to this. I have been conducted a bit of analysis of our server access file to see what googlebot is doing, where it is going etc. Now firstly, I am not SEO but have an interest. What I am seeing a lot of is that we have URL's that have an extension that sets the currency that is displayed on the products so that we can conduct Adwords campaigns in other countries, these show as follows: feedurl=AUD, feedurl=USD, feedurl=EUR etc. What I can see is that google bot is hitting a URL such as /some_product, then /someproduct?feedurl=USD and then /someproduct?feedurl=EUR and then /someproduct?feedurl=AUD all after each other. Now this is the same product page and just has the price shown slightly different on each. Would this count as a duplicate content issue? Should I disavow feedurl? Any assistance that you can offer would be greatly appreciated. Thanks, Tim
Technical SEO | | timsilver0 -
Duplicate Tag Content Mystery
Hello Moz Communtiy! i am also having error of Duplicate Tag Content Mystery like: http://www.earnmoneywithgoogleadsense.com/tag/blog-post/ http://www.earnmoneywithgoogleadsense.com/tag/effective-blog-post/ Pages are same. I have 100+ Error on website so how can i remove this error? DO you have any tutorial based on this? Can i change canonical url at once or i need to set it one by one? If you have any video basis on it, i will recommend.
Technical SEO | | navneetkumar7860 -
Content relaunch without content duplication
We write great Content for blog and websites (or at least we try), especially blogs. Sometimes few of them may NOT get good responses/reach. It could be the content which is not interesting, or the title, or bad timing or even the language used. My question for the discussion is, what will you do if you find the content worth audience's attention missed it during its original launch. Is that fine to make the text and context better and relaunch it ? For example: 1. Rechristening the blog - Change Title to make it attractive
Technical SEO | | macronimous
2. Add images
3. Check spelling
4. Do necessary rewrite, spell check
5. Change the timeline by adding more recent statistics, references to recent writeups (external and internal blogs for example), change anything that seems outdated Also, change title and set rel=cannoical / 301 permanent URLs. Will the above make the blog new? Any ideas and tips to do? Basically we like to refurbish (:-)) content that didn't succeed in the past and relaunch it to try again. If we do so will there be any issues with Google bots? (I hope redirection would solve this, But still I want to make sure) Thanks,0 -
URL Mixed Cases and Duplicate Content
Hi There, I have a question for you. I am working on a website where by typing any letter of the URL in lower or upper case, it will give a 200 code. Examples www.examples.com/page1/product www.examples.com/paGe1/Product www.examples.com/PagE1/prOdUcT www.examples.com/pAge1/proODUCt and so on… Although I cannot find evidence of backlinks pointing to my page with mixed cases, shall I redirect or rel=canonical all the possible combination of the cases to a lower version of them in order to prevent duplicate content? And if so, do you have any advice on how to complete such a massive job? Thanks a lot
Technical SEO | | Midleton0 -
Duplicate content issues, I am running into challenges and am looking for suggestions for solutions. Please help.
So I have a number of pages on my real estate site that display the same listings, even when parsed down by specific features and don't want these to come across as duplicate content pages. Here are a few examples: http://luxuryhomehunt.com/homes-for-sale/lake-mary/hanover-woods.html?feature=waterfront http://luxuryhomehunt.com/homes-for-sale/lake-mary/hanover-woods.html This happens to be a waterfront community so all the homes are located along the waterfront. I can use a canonical tag, but I not every community is like this and I want the parsed down feature pages to get index. Here is another example that is a little different: http://luxuryhomehunt.com/homes-for-sale/winter-park/bear-gully-bay.html http://luxuryhomehunt.com/homes-for-sale/winter-park/bear-gully-bay.html?feature=without-pool http://luxuryhomehunt.com/homes-for-sale/winter-park/bear-gully-bay.html?feature=4-bedrooms http://luxuryhomehunt.com/homes-for-sale/winter-park/bear-gully-bay.html?feature=waterfront So all the listings in this community happen to have 4 bedrooms, no pool, and are waterfront. Meaning that they display for each of the parsed down categories. I can possible set something that if the listings = same then use canonical of main page url, but in the next case its not so simple. So in this next neighborhood there are 48 total listings as seen at: http://luxuryhomehunt.com/homes-for-sale/windermere/isleworth.html and being that it is a higher end neighborhood, 47 of the 48 listings are considered "traditional listings" and while it is not exactly all of them it is 99%. Any recommendations is appreciated greatly.
Technical SEO | | Jdubin0 -
Lots of duplicate content warnings
I have a site that says that I have 2,500 warnings. It is a real estate website and of course we use feeds. it says I have a lot of duplicate content. One thing is a page called "Request an appointment" and that is a url for each listing. Since there are 800 listings on my site. How could I solve this problem so that this doesn't show up as duplicate content since I use the same "Request an Appointment" verbeage on each of those? I guess my developer who used php to do it, created a dedicated url to each. Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Technical SEO | | SeaC0