Selling Paid Directories
-
Hello Mozzers!
Like most, we have greatly reduced the number of paid directories in which we enroll our clients. We do, however, still utilize a few. For those of you still using select paid directories, what approach do you take in marketing these sites to your clients?
Thanks in advance for your input!
-
Hi Frank,
Thanks for the additional info on this and for clarifying that the business models are local and well-acquainted with the role citations play in Local Search Marketing. What follows is just my opinion, based on what I've seen over the years.
I've honestly never been a fan of any paid local directory, though some people swear by them. You shouldn't be having to pay for a BOTW listing. Unless I've totally missed something, I'm pretty sure those are still free (https://secure.botw.org/secure/Signup.aspx?type=jumpstart&directory=local). I'm not familiar with the benefits of Business.com and have never submitted a client to them, so I'm afraid I can't speak to that.
If my clients were in the hospitality industry, I'd make sure I'd covered their citations in as many of the free generic local directories as possible and then be sure they were enrolled in any industry specific directories that do drive traffic/bookings to hotels, even if these were paid ones. Beyond this, I'd devote resources to content development and social outreach rather than paid generic directories. I'd predict a better return from that kind of effort.
-
Hi Miriam,
Thanks for the response.
I sent this same reply to Wayne, but would also like your input.
Our clients are all hotels of various sizes and market segments. As such, we focus on local citation building. We also utilize all of the appropriate local citations listed on the page you referenced above. We used to do much more paid directory work, but have tried to reduce it as they have come to lose value. Currently we only enroll clients in BOTW and Business.com, as Yahoo has discontinued their directory. Could you provide your thoughts on those two examples, keeping in mind that they drive very little direct traffic, and zero revenue. We are merely using them for their statistical value.
Thanks!
Frank
-
HI Wayne,
Thanks for the response. Our clients are all hotels of various sizes and market segments. As such, we focus on local citation building. We also utilize all of the appropriate local citations listed on the page you referenced above. We used to do much more paid directory work, but have tried to reduce it as they have come to lose value. Currently we only enroll clients in BOTW and Business.com, as Yahoo has discontinued their directory. Could you provide your thoughts on those two examples, keeping in mind that they drive very little direct traffic, and zero revenue. We are merely using them for their statistical value.
Thanks!
Frank
-
Hey Frank!
As Wayne has pointed out, the use of directory listings is still alive and well in the Local SEO world. You didn't mention whether your clients have a local or national focus, but if it's the former, then this type of work (called citation building) is a core part of a local search marketing campaign.
-
Hi Frank!
That term "paid directory" can send shivers through an SEO'er. The reason? Directories were long exploited by--_TA-DA!--_SEO'ers!
That said, there is absolutely nothing wrong with employing the use of a directory paid or non if it's relevant and carries authority. This is especially true with regard to niche categories and the need for citations. These citations often help with local listings and are obtained by way of directories.
A great tool you can use to illustrate same is MOZ's Top Local Citations by Category page. As you scan your client's industry and look at the results it provides, you'll quickly see that not only are there a host of directories, many of them are paid. Paid directories aren't always a bad thing, but you certainly want to be careful and selective.
Hope this helps!
Wayne
-
I would not try to sell this anymore, the times have changed and unless those directories are driving conversions I would avoid them, paid directories have no place in SEO according to Google.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Creating Local Listings for Small Business Clients - Verifying if phone call is only verification option? Are directory submission services worth it?
I'm relatively new to local SEO --- I do a lot of local websites for small businesses (restaurants, bars, hotels, attorneys, dentists) in my area and thought it would make sense to include basic local SEO work with my websites. I have a couple of questions about adding my client's businesses to local business directories... I've started by adding each business to Google, Bing, and Yahoo business listings. I verified these listings with the postcard option which my clients then email to me. I've started adding them to additional directories but have found that many local directories require a phone call to the business to verify it (no other options). How do most SEO companies handle this? Do I ask them to forward their phone to mine for a night? Does it make sense to do local directory submission by hand? I created a spreadsheet for each company and keep track of each directory I submit to (the directory name, verification status, and username & password). I looked at services like Yext but doubt they are as thorough as doing it by hand? Any other advice on local business directory submission would greatly be appreciated. Thanks.
Link Building | | RustySmith0 -
This directory looks great - would you agree?
I know people have mixed feelings towards submitting their sites to directories, but this one really seemed special, so I decided to share the opportunity with the Moz community, as well as open up a discussion on the value of being a part of this directory (and similar ones.) We recently submitted our site to Dial a Human (www.dialahuman.com) It is a directory of companies' phone numbers, which go directly to a person (bypassing the machines.) I think this directory actually does provide users with value, and is far from your typical link farm. The Page Authority is 56 and the Domain Authority is 47, and it is a PR5 site. The other companies listed are all extremely reputable (most of them are fortune 500 companies.) The fee to join is $75-$150, but to be included with this group of companies, we felt it was very worthwhile. We would join this type of directory over and over again. Would you? If you have any other directories which are of the same caliber please share!
Link Building | | JMacSupply0 -
What do you consider a low authority link directory
Dear All, I would like to weed out the low authority link directories that harm my site. Can someone explain me how you determine a low authority link directory? Do you look at "page auth." and "domain auth"? And do you consider all the links pointing to your site with a "page auth." and "domain auth" lower then - let's say 40 - as a low authority link directory? Thank you for your answers in advance! Regards, Thomas
Link Building | | ThomasH0 -
When is it time to buy a $100+ paid directory listing?
I have been working on a site for 11 months, everything is looking great. Apart from a small amount of highly important keywords which rank #2 to #5. 1. How will I know if I need to invest in a paid directory? 2. Will one listing be enough to make a difference? I am looking at a listing at BOTW.org. Other recommendations welcome.
Link Building | | ClassifiedsKing0 -
Directories
Hi SEOMOZ'ers I am trying to find high quality directories to submit links, finding it really hard to find them!! Has anyone got any advise for seeking out such sites! I have tried the tool within SEOMOZ but to be honest did not really work that well! thanks Daniel
Link Building | | dan1el0 -
What are your views on link submitters / directory submitters?
I have no real opinion on them to be honest, I don't really have any experience with them personally: eg: http://www.fastdirectorysubmitter.com/downloads.html http://www.thelinksubmitter.com/ http://www.dumpblaster.com/ I presume they will be negative or a waste of time?
Link Building | | Benj250 -
Thoughts on 2 directories?
Thoughts on ScrubTheWeb.com and SearchSight.com ? would directories like these be a good idea? We are a b to b company... Thanks!
Link Building | | inhouseninja0 -
Which Directory Sites to Choose?
Hi All I am a newbie to SEO and have a quick Q. Assuming that appropriate steps would be to; a) Ensure all onsite matters are are correct, title tags, meta descriptions, redirects, canonical issues. b) Submit to Directories c) Build Links I am approaching step b) Which Directories are worth submitting to? For those which require payment, how can I decide which are value for money or should I just use SEOMOZ list of links and assume that theyre worth the $50 - $100 if my higher ranking competitors have links from these directories. Also, can this be looked opon as grey/black hat 'buying of links'? Thank you Sean www.pretavoir.co.uk
Link Building | | seanmccauley0