Why is this working for a competitor? Non-relevant backlinks helping them out?
-
A competitor is using a weird strategy, one I know isn't legit, however it's not only helping them, but doing in with a lot of speed.
I've ran their info through ahref, majestic, moz, semrush and for backlinks they have 225ish, here is their breakdown.
169 follow links from their parent distributor site ( which is located in their parent's site's footer )
and then 3 to 5 links from sites that relate to SEO, marketing, unrelated things like pocket calling article and comment spam.
maybe 5 of those links are from anywhere close to a related site, and those are from spammy directories from out of country.
Why would these backlinks be helping them so much, and how can I get in front of them when these craptactics are working for them?
They have 250 backlinks - 25 of them are follow
We have 300 backlinks - 90 are follow and from relevant sites like EPA.gov, some EDUs and related sites to our niche.
Some explanations or words of wit would really be helpful here, as I feel like something isn't adding up.
-
It's pretty hard, even from a creative standpoint ( of which I have experience in as an artist / maker )
After:
- content marketing
- scholarships ( only a few, were not rich )
- projects on manufacturers sites
- proper directories that people still use
- sending our resource links to service oriented sites for their customers
- Local businesses in form of local directory
The backlink grab bag grows smaller and smaller for this niche, gotta remember that our niche is so small and particular that mobile and tablet traffic isn't big at all, since our most popular customer type is a male in their 40s - 50s working either as a contractor or a small biz owner. There aren't many sites that even talk about our niche, let alone people actively interested in it, unless they need them.
I've been struggling for the past 6 months on backlinks, and previous SEO companies have as well before me. It's bad enough that when I do competitor backlink audits, I see the same directories, spam comments, article spins, unrelated content like article spinning and lots of sister sites being created just to link back and forth to.
Any suggestions in the creative backlink field would be honored at this point. As it is now, I send out about 10 to 15 emails daily to sites I feel would benefit from our large amount of help content I've created over the last 6 months, something our niche competitors have slacked bad on, while our customer's have called and complimented us on it, other sites could care less, even more so when I ask to link back in some " clever or even outright " fashion.
-
Good questions...
1. No, it is not good practice to get links from an SEO site or unrelated sites, but that doesn't mean Google will catch it.
2. Sometimes, unrelated links are really good. For example, imagine a customer leaving a review for you on their own blog.
3. There is very little evidence that the relevancy of the linking page actually promotes rankings.I doubt that it is really harder to win the lottery than to get links, even in NSFW niches. You just have to be creative.
-
Hello and thanks for responding,
What confuses me is where their follow links come from,
How is it even good practice to have backlinks from my own personal SEO site, or an article about phone calls when I sell commercial building supplies? Not to mention the bulk of their links having nothing to do with their niche that their site operates in?
Google says to get backlinks from relevant sites, this is where I am not following. How do they even have good links, if they aren't relative to commercial building supplies? And since they aren't relevant why are they helping them out so much? I've been following this site for the past 5 months, I can answer almost any question you might have about them.
Please ask a few to gather what you would need to know so maybe I could stop tearing my hair out.
As to the gathering good backlinks, in our niche, you're more likely to win the mega millions with one ticket ( goes out an plays ).
-
Thanks for the question. It would be hard to know exactly without seeing the example sites, but there are many possible issues at play...
1. Is the competitor site using manipulated anchor text (ie: keywords as anchor text)
2. Do their links tend to point to the homepage while yours are dispersed across your site?
3. Is it possible they have other sources of links which aren't disclosed in 3rd party tools (like a 301 redirected site that blocks links)There are any number of potential issues here. However, judging from the numbers you describe, there seems be a really simple solution... go get more good links!
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Content Calendar Help
Hey guys, I am about to start creating a content calendar that I will be using to pitch blogs and news websites with the goal of gaining a link and driving traffic to my site. Do you guys have some bookmarked links that can help me follow a step by step process on how to develop a content calendar? I'm looking at something like what tools to use, how to figure out what's hot in a particular niche, social media topics, etc. Thanks in advance!
Link Building | | Workaholic0 -
Backlinks: What are they really and how can I create them.
I am relatively new to the SEO world, and I want to build backlinks linking to our main site. My preferred way to create backlinks is by adding them in my blog comments or forum responses. I am an active participant in a large number of blogs/forums related to our field and I would like to add relevant backlinks in the comments/answers I post. I originally thought that a backlink was just a link, but none of the links that I have added to blogs like that have been recognized as backlinks. https://www.dynaread.com/ Why is this so? I know now that good backlink would be something like: Dynaread is a science based dyslexia remediation program for older struggling readers. However I have no idea how to add this types of links to blog comments or forum pages where there is no link tool. Do I have to do something with HTML? Please explain briefly what a backlink really is and most importantly how I can create them. Thank you in advance for your help! Joy P.S if you have suggestions about some resources where I can learn more about the subject please let me know. I love to learn more.
Link Building | | Dynaread0 -
Best place to outsource backlinking services?
Hi, I have been doing "lite" SEO on my site for several years and have achieved some decent ranking for relevant terms. I have good solid content and and am simply in need of quality backlinks to boost my SERPs. I stopped doing SEO because I was focused on development of the site for about 6 months and lost about half of my traffic as a result. In the past I have used rentacoder, guru, and odesk for software development, but does anyone know the best one to find decent SEO consultant/content writers? I want to start out at about $300/month for back links and ramp up from there. Also, The last company I hired provided almost all links from India spam sites, however, I still noticed a steady increase in rankings over a few months. Thought on thats? Thanks!
Link Building | | lane06180 -
Link Building in non-competitive industry
Hello, My client's home page is targething 2 keywords - one at 43% difficulty (SEOMoz Keyword Difficulty Tool) and one at 50% difficulty. I want to link build for this person, but I analyzed the top 5 competitors and there is no resource section on any of the sites. We want to write 20 articles for our site. So there's no people linking to content that I can find. This messes up my link building because I always make targeted content on the subject that people are already linking to How do I link build in this case. Nothing stands out as something I could do with my site for link bait. Thanks!
Link Building | | BobGW0 -
Should I Just Copy A Competitor's Backlinks?
Forgive the newbie question, but now that I have found SeoMoz and OpenSiteExplorer, should I just piggy back on my competitors backlinks? What would be the downside? By way of explanation, I've never had the need to explore SEO before. Our site, Widgets.com has always ranked highly for all Widgets keywords because we have the keyword in our domain and our site has been around since 1998. But out of the blue this summer, a site, let's call them WidgetsCircus.com suddenly began outranking us on widgets keywords, and pretty much every keyword we can imagine in our little widget universe. Now that I have run OpenSiteExplorer, I can see how they've done it. They've pretty much spent the last year commenting on blog posts all over the place, editing wiki pages, etc., and built thousands of links for all these widget keywords. So, I'm wondering: why shouldn't I just go down the list of links and do exactly what they've done? Where they commented on a blog, why don't I just comment right along side them. Obviously, this has worked for them! Wouldn't it work for us too? Or is that too simple?
Link Building | | brianmcc0 -
Who are my competitors
Hello, Quick question. for the term "NLP" and the site nlpca.com I'm analyzing backlinks of competitors. Is wikipedia a competitor, or are competitors only sites like mine. I'm thinking that if someone links to wikipedia they wouldn't necessarily want to link to nlpca.com Thus, should I still analyze wikipedia? Thank you.
Link Building | | BobGW0 -
Press Release Sites for Backlinks
OK, I read a previous thread about whether people found press release sites useful (specifically I am considering a reputable pay for release service). I understand the knock on press releases in this digital age (namely that no one reads them and arguably never did . . . ), but I was interested in moving the discussion in a different direction . . . Do press releases services really help a sites performance based on increased backlinking? Is there a SEO benefit to PR services? My company is a local print company. I've done quite a bit of research on my local competitors, and specifically for a couple products we would like to dominate. The good news is that it looks like the hurdle would not be terribly high to really take over the web presence with a well planned and executed website/SEO campaign. My inclination is that for a relatively small company like mine (dealing with relatively small competitors) it WOULD benefit me to pay for the sheer number of backlinks a PR program would generate. The monthly cost is frankly about the same as the cost of this site, which OF COURSE I get value from (hey moderator, how about a couple extra MOZ points for that one!) Specifically, I am looking at this for myself, but feel free to expand the question to the broader topic.
Link Building | | damon12121 -
Backlinks from embeded Wistia video?
If I use Wistia for my videos, and somebody embeds my video on their site, can I get a backlink from this?
Link Building | | gregalam0