Issue with duplicate content
-
Hello guys, i have a question about duplicate content. Recently I noticed that MOZ's system reports a lot of duplicate content on one of my sites. I'm a little confused what i should do with that because this content is created automatically. All the duplicate content comes from subdomain of my site where we actually share cool images with people. This subdomain is actually pointing to our Tumblr blog where people re-blog our posts and images a lot.
I'm really confused how all this duplicate content is created and what i should do to prevent it. Please tell me whether i need to "noindex", "nofollow" that subdomain or you can suggest something better to resolve that issue.
Thank you!
-
Peter, i'm trying to PM you but i have no idea what to place in the "recepient" field. Thank you for assistance.
-
We only crawl your own site, so we wouldn't surface a duplicate with Tumblr, unless something really, really weird is going on. This is why I need to look at the campaign - what you're describing shouldn't happen, in theory, so I have a feeling this is a pretty unusual situation.
-
Hello Peter, thank you for helping!
Peter, why do you say that neither Moz nor Webmaster Tools are going to detect the duplicates between your subdomain and Tumblr? MOZ is detecting it now. Can you more elaborate on it?
THanks
-
My gut feeling is that you have 2+ issues going on here. Neither Moz nor Webmaster Tools are going to detect the duplicates between your subdomain and Tumblr. So, we/they, must be seeing duplicates in the subdomain itself. This sounds like an overly-complex setup that is likely to be causing you some harm, but without seeing it in play, it's really hard to diagnose.
Could you PM me with the domain - I can log into Moz Analytics as you and check, but you have a few campaigns set up.
(Sorry, I originally was logged in as Marina and my reply posted - I apologize for the confusion)
-
Hello Kane,
Thank you for trying to help me!
I added a link to three screenshots. Two of them are from my MOZ account showing exponential increase of duplicate content and the second one is the subdomain where that duplicate content is coming from. The third screenshot is from my gmail account showing notification from GWT about deep links issue. I'm not sure whether these two issues have anything in common but i fell that they do. Please let me know what you think.
Thanks
-
Hi Marina, a few questions for you:
Can you possibly post screenshots of the Google Webmaster Tools warning that you're seeing?
Does your website have an app associated with it?
Assuming your Tumblr content isn't reposted somewhere on your main domain, it doesn't seem like a duplicate content issue to me, it seems like the GWT message is related to deep linking for a mobile app. I can't imagine why you'd get that if you don't have an app.
-
Thank you for help!
Answering your questions:-
My subdomain look like this: photos.domain.com and it was poined to Tumblr platform (our blog on Tumblr) because it is very image-fiendly platform as well as they host all the images.
-
We use this subdomain only for images posting. We don't use this content on our root domain at all.
I'm really confused what Android app they are talking about. Do the consider Tumblr as Android app?
Thanks
-
-
Hi there
Do you have a web development team or a web developer? What I would do is pass this notification over to them, along with your notifications from Moz, and see if they have a means to correct these issues. I am assuming that Google passed along resources in their notification; I would look into those and see what your options are.
If you do not have a web development team, I would check out the Recommended List to find a company that does web development as well as SEO that can assist in this. What it sounds like to me is that you are linking off to an app with a subdomain and it's creating a different user experience than the one generated by your website.
If I were you, I would find a suitable blogging platform that you can bring your sharing capabilities onto, and create a consistent and seamless experience for your users. Two questions:
- Is your subdomain blog.domain.com? Or is it named differently?
- Do you have your blog posts on your website and copied word for word on your subdomain?
Here are a couple of more resources to review with your team:
App Indexing for Google Search Overview What is App Indexing?
App Indexing for Google Search Technical Details Enabling Deep Links for App ContentLet me know if any of this helps or if you have any more comments - good luck!
-
Thank you for replies!
I'm fairly well aware about duplicate content issue but i have never faced such particular issue. As Lesley said i don't have access to head sections of each post because those posts are practically not on my property but on Tumblr's. And i have no idea how it is created. I assume that it is cause by Tumblr's feature that allows users to re-blog my blog posts.
Moreover, i've just received a warning from Google Webmaster Tools specifically pertaining this subdomain. I'm really confused. Please help
Fix app deep links to ....com/ that dont match the content of the web pages
Dear webmaster
When indexing the deep links to your app, we detected that the content of 1 app pages doesnt match the content of the corresponding web page. This is a bad experience for your users because they wont find what they were looking for on your app page. We wont show deep links for these app pages in our smartphone search results. This is an important issue that needs your immediate attention.
Take these actions to fix this issue:
- Check the Android Apps section of the Crawl Errors report in Webmaster Tools to find examples of app URIs whose content doesnt match their corresponding web page.
- Use these examples to debug the issue:
- Open the corresponding web page to have it ready.
- Use Android debug bridge to open the app page.
- Make sure the content on both your web page and your app page is the same.
- If necessary, change the content on your app (or change your sitemap / or rel=alternate element associations to make sure the each app page is connected to the right web page).
- If necessary, change your robots.txt file to allow crawling of relevant resources. This mismatch might also be due to the fact that some of the resources associated with the app page are disallowed from crawling though robots.txt.
-
I am not very experienced with tumblr personally, but I am pretty sure it cannot be done because they don't give you access to what you would need. You would need access to the head section of each page so that you could put the canonical tag in.
One thing that MIGHT could work, but would be tricky and I would also consult with someone else about too, to see what they though. Is that if the url's are the same minus the sub domain, you could get apache to rewrite a canonical in the actual request header and send it over. I do not know if google would respect this, so I would ask others advice.
-
Hi there
The only time you should noindex a site is if it's not supposed to be seen by search engines - if that's the case, then noindex it.
However, if this content is supposed to be seen by search engines, I would make use of your canonical tags on the subdomain and point it to the original content on the domain.
I would also think of a way to build a community with your website - it sounds like you have opportunities to do so and are getting some attention from your audience and how they are sharing your posts and information.
Also, look into sitemap opportunities with your images and how you can help crawlers understand the information on your website.
You can read more about duplicate content here.
Hope this helps a bit! Let me know if you have any questions or comments!
-
Hello Lesley,
Thank you for response! Well, the subdomain is pointing to our Tumblr blog. I have access to both main domain and Tumblr. Where should i add canonical?Thanks
-
Do you have control over the sub domain to add a canonical to it and point the canonical to the original content?
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Best Way to Handle Near-Duplicate Content?
Hello Dear MOZers, Having duplicate content issues and I'd like some opinions on how best to deal with this problem. Background: I run a website for a cosmetic surgeon in which the most valuable content area is the section of before/after photos of our patients. We have 200+ pages (one patient per page) and each page has a 'description' block of text and a handful of before and after photos. Photos are labeled with very similar labels patient-to-patient ("before surgery", "after surgery", "during surgery" etc). Currently, each page has a unique rel=canonical tag. But MOZ Crawl Diagnostics has found these pages to be duplicate content of each other. For example, using a 'similar page checker' two of these pages were found to be 97% similar. As far as I understand there are a few ways to deal with this, and I'd like to get your opinions on the best course. Add 150+ more words to each description text block Prevent indexing of patient pages with robots.txt Set the rel=canonical for each patient page to the main gallery page Any other options or suggestions? Please keep in mind that this is our most valuable content, so I would be reluctant to make major structural changes, or changes that would result in any decrease in traffic to these pages. Thank you folks, Ethan
Technical SEO | | BernsteinMedicalNYC0 -
When is Duplicate Content Duplicate Content
Hi, I was wondering exactly when duplicate content is duplicate content? Is it always when it is word-for-word or if it is similar? For example, we currently have an information page and I would like to add a FAQ to the website. There is, however, a crossover with the content and some of it is repeated. However, it is not written word for word. Could you please advise me? Thanks a lot Tom
Technical SEO | | National-Homebuyers0 -
Joomla: content accesible through all kinds of other links >> duplicate content?!
When i did a site: search on Google i've noticed all kind of URL's on my site were indexed, while i didn't add them to the Joomla navigation (or they were not linked anywhere on the site). Some examples: www.domain.com/1-articlename >> that way ALL articles are publicly visible, even if they are not linked to a menu-item... If by accident such a link get's shared it will be indexed in google, you can have 2 links with same content... www.domain.com/2-uncategorised >> same with categories, automatically these overview pages are visible to people who know this URL. On it you see all the articles that belong to that category. www.domain.com/component/content >> this gives an overview of all the categories inside your Joomla CMS I think most will agree this is not good for your site's SEO? But how can this be solved? Is this some kind of setting within Joomla? Anyone who dealt with these problems already?
Technical SEO | | conversal0 -
Duplicate content /index.php/ issues
I'm having some duplicate content issues with Google. I've already got my .htaccess file working just fine as far as I can tell. Rewriting works great, and by using the site you'd never end up on a page with /index.php. However I do notice that on ANY page of the site you could add /index.php and get the same page i.e.: www.mysite.com/category/article and www.mysite.com/index.php/category/article Would both return the same page. How can I 301 or something similar all /index.php pages to the non index.php version? I have no desire for any page on my site to have index.php in it, there is no use to it. Having quite the hard time figuring this out. Again this is basically just for the robots, the URL's the users see are perfect, never had an issue with that. Just SEOMOZ reporting duplicate content and I've verified that to be true.
Technical SEO | | b18turboef1 -
Duplicate Content for Multiple Instances of the Same Product?
Hi again! We're set to launch a new inventory-based site for a chain of car dealers with various locations across the midwest. Here's our issue: The different branches have overlap in the products that they sell, and each branch is adamant that their inventory comes up uniquely in site search. We don't want the site to get penalized for duplicate content; however, we don't want to implement a link rel=canonical because each product should carry the same weight in search. We've talked about having a basic URL for these product descriptions, and each instance of the inventory would be canonicalized to this main product, but it doesn't really make sense for the site structure to do this. Do you have any tips on how to ensure that these products (same description, new product from manufacturer) won't be penalized as duplicate content?
Technical SEO | | newwhy0 -
Why are my pages getting duplicate content errors?
Studying the Duplicate Page Content report reveals that all (or many) of my pages are getting flagged as having duplicate content because the crawler thinks there are two versions of the same page: http://www.mapsalive.com/Features/audio.aspx http://www.mapsalive.com/Features/Audio.aspx The only difference is the capitalization. We don't have two versions of the page so I don't understand what I'm missing or how to correct this. Anyone have any thoughts for what to look for?
Technical SEO | | jkenyon0 -
Canonical Link for Duplicate Content
A client of ours uses some unique keyword tracking for their landing pages where they append certain metrics in a query string, and pulls that information out dynamically to learn more about their traffic (kind of like Google's UTM tracking). Non-the-less these query strings are now being indexed as separate pages in Google and Yahoo and are being flagged as duplicate content/title tags by the SEOmoz tools. For example: Base Page: www.domain.com/page.html
Technical SEO | | kchandler
Tracking: www.domain.com/page.html?keyword=keyword#source=source Now both of these are being indexed even though it is only one page. So i suggested placing an canonical link tag in the header point back to the base page to start discrediting the tracking URLs: But this means that the base pages will be pointing to themselves as well, would that be an issue? Is their a better way to solve this issue without removing the query tracking all togther? Thanks - Kyle Chandler0 -
Avoiding duplicate content/same pages
hi I have been checking through all the Q and A but i i'm still not sure how you get http://www.domain.co.uk/index.html to be just http://www.domain.co.uk/? Do you add canonical to the index page to point to the page you prefer and then add a 301 redirect? thanks
Technical SEO | | challen0