On December 30th, 2015 I decided to look at the Moz Community Rankings, I find it fun to do for time to time, and I always like to see how close I am to getting that special dinner with Rand I have heard so much about in the past.
One thing I noticed right away is that Moz ranks members just on MozPoints, and not on other factors like, how helpful they tend to be. This means had I joined in a few years earlier, I could be at the top.. or could I be???
Again, it is just something I did for fun, but I decided to look at a few additional factors to get my True MozRank
By examining just the top 50 active members I added some additional ranking factors and aggregated them to find a true Rank. The ranking factors are..
- Moz Points Per Month (Using the users points divided by months they have been a member)
- Thumbs Up percentage (Using the percentage of Thumbs Up they receive per point)
- Good Answer percentage (Using the percentage of Good Answers they receive per point)
- Endorsed Answer percentage (Using the percentage of Endorsed Answers they receive per point)
After that I gave each of the top 50 a rank in each category based on their respective scores. I then totaled the ranks, and assigned a new final rank based on the lowest totals (which means they ranked the best).
Edit (01/18/2016): With the help of Peter Nikolow I aggregated all active users as per this post.
Link to all 4291 active users ranks
For example EGOL category ranks:
- MozPoint Rank (1)
- Points Per Month Rank (2)
- Percent of Thumbs Up Rank (27)
- Percent of Good Answers Rank (29)
- Percent of Endorsed Answers Rank (23)
Total = 82
Final Rank = 5
His closest competitor RyanKent MozPoint Points rank 2
- MozPoint Rank (2)
- Points Per Month Rank (3)
- Percent of Thumbs Up Rank (39)
- Percent of Good Answers Rank (9)
- Percent of Endorsed Answers Rank (20)
Total = 73
Final Rank = 2
Well it was a fun experiment for me, a couple people are out of place in the rankings based on other factors but for the most part MozPoints are pretty accurate.
You can view the spread sheet on Google Docs and play around with the data as you wish.
Don
EDIT: After looking at the document again I noticed an error with rank assignments I have since fixed it.
Edit (01/18/2016): With the help of Peter Nikolow I aggregated all active users as per this post. Link to all 4291 active users ranks